A lot of online Halloween themed drink recipes call for really expensive ingredients. Well, I'm not exactly loaded so I made up some of my own, cheap and simple but tasty recipes. I also found ways to make them more.. festive. First, lets start with the cups...
I do this the night before the party. First, set out a ton of plastic cups. Orange and black are the usual colors I use. Leave some set aside for people who don't want sugar on theirs -boring! Take a plate and mix sugar crystal sprinkles of Halloween colors together. My favorite mix is black, orange, green and purple. Then, take another plate and pour a bit of Caro syrup (any type of corn syrup works), on the plate, just enough to cover it really. Next, dip the rims -ONLY- of the cups into the syrup. Gently shake off any excess syrup. then touch the syrup to the sprinkles on the other plate. Make sure the rim is coated with sugar and let dry. If the sugar gets too clumpy with syrup, wash off the plate and make a new one. If your cups drip, use less syrup.
Now for the drinks. Obviously, its always good to have lots of soda and beer (for the adult parties), but its fun to have other stuff too. The key to making boring things look more spooky is labels! Labels turn "Koolaid and Vodka" into "Bog Water" or "The Black Plague." Plus, its best to have clearly labeled drinks so people who can't have alcohol (drivers, pregnant women, etc), can still join in on the fun.
For my black drinks, I mix Orange and grape Koolaid together. Then I add rainbow sherbert. The real trick? Beforehand, I take the rainbow sherbert and let it melt a little on the counter. Then I stir in some black food coloring and mix it into a nasty looking blackish brown mess. Throwing lumps of the icky looking but tasty sherbert adds some texture and bubbles. For the alcoholic one, I just add a bunch of vodka, until it has a nice kick.
For the "Swamp Water," I use lemon-lime Koolaid, Sprite and some stirred rainbow sherbet. I don't dye the sherbert for this, just stir until its a disgusting looking brown. Then I add gummy eyeballs from Walmart. They INSIST on floating upside down and the start to disintegrate after a bit, making the gross lumpy stuff that floats on top. Of course, it <i>tastes</i> wonderful, but it looks nasty.